After 18 hours of research evaluating 115 products, we picked Custom Catch Personalized Dog Collar as our top choice.
So, you wanna make your dog a pimp? We’d suggest getting him a snazzy new dog collar. Of course, not just any collar will do. There are a number of things to think about before purchasing a new piece of neck bling such as age and size of your dog.
The American Kennel Club recommends different types of dog collars for your puppy and dog companions based on those factors.
You may find that the best dog collar for your pooch isn’t one of the more basic designs—and that’s totally fine.
If you have a dog who likes to chew, a leather collar is probably best. If you have one with a tendency to run away, a shock collar could be the right option. Or maybe you think your furry companion needs an extra dose of bling. There are personalized dog collars for that, too.
Finding the best dog collar is the first of many choices you need to make as a dog owner. Of course, there’s finding the right dog food and the most comfortable dog bed, too. So, when you’re done finding that best dog collar, don’t forget to check out our other guides.
The AKC recommends the PetSafe martingale collar as a safer and softer alternative to the traditional choke collar. So, if you’re concerned with the amount of pressure being put on your dog’s neck, this is a good collar to try instead.
Sizing may be tricky with these (since you have the extra loop that loosens and tightens), so be extra cautious when buying these as customers have complained about their dogs slipping out of them.
Style: Martingale collars are similar to basic dog collars in that they’re typically made of nylon. However, a Martingale collar like this one cannot be secured with a clasp or buckle. Instead, they’re slipped over a dog’s head so that the collar remains somewhat loose while you walk. While training, if they (or you) pull on the leash, the collar tightens like a choker.
Comfort: This will be just as comfortable as a basic collar; however, don’t leave this on your dog while they’re chilling out at home. Customers have expressed concerns about dogs choking/strangling themselves while they’re not at home (it’s just due to the construction of a Martingale).
Security: This has been a problem for some customers. While the collar will stay in place when tightened, if you don’t pick up the proper size, your dog may be able to slip out of it.
Price: This is super cheap, which is surprising what with how well-made PetSafe products are.
Everyone seems to rave about the Sprenger prong training collar more than any other, so they definitely deserve a spot on our list if you’re in need of something stronger than a Martingale when training your dog. This one is easy to get off and on your dog, has a built-in plate to protect your dog’s trachea in case of pulling, and is great for training.
Some people have said they don’t know how to get the collar off or on the dog, so be sure to review the instructions and work with a certified trainer before using this collar on your dog.
Style: This is a metal prong collar used for training dogs as well as keeping larger and stronger dogs in line when you walk them. As the collar tightens, the prongs push into the dogs neck, letting them know they need to ease up, and customers say it works wonders for obedience.
Comfort: There haven’t been any real issues reported with discomfort. So long as you get the right size and use it properly, your dog should be just fine wearing this.
Security: Once the collar is secured, you shouldn’t have any problems at all with your dog slipping out of this one.
Price: In terms of dog training collars go, this is about mid-range on price.
If what you need is a basic dog collar that stays secured, fits well, and looks great, then this one from RC Pet Products might be perfect for your pooch. It comes in a great selection of colors and it does exactly what you need it to do.
Be careful with sizing on this one as some customers have complained about the collar being too loose.
Style: This is just your standard dog collar: adjustable, soft webbing, ID ring attached, with a secure plastic buckle.
Comfort: This is something customers love most about this product, so if you’re trying to find a collar that’s comfortable for your dog this might be the place to start.
Security: So far, no one’s really made any complaints about the security of this collar. It’s well-made, so you won’t have to worry about ID tags coming off, the buckle breaking, or your dog chewing through it.
Price: This is absolutely a great value.
If you like the idea of getting a heavy-duty collar for your dog while also giving back to rescue dogs in need, then give this collar a gander. It’s good and thick, so it’ll keep your dog from chewing it off, and is otherwise really well-made so you shouldn’t have to worry about your dog breaking free or ruining this one.
Some people have had issues with the color of the collar bleeding onto their dog’s light fur. It doesn’t happen often, but there have been a few noted cases.
Style: Just your standard dog collar, except that it comes with a belt-like closure instead of a plastic buckle or clasp.
Comfort: We haven’t seen any complaints regarding discomfort with this collar.
Security: This collar is made with a thick double layer off nylon to ensure durability and chew-proofing for crazy pups that want to pull a vanishing act. It also uses a secure metal belt buckle to fasten, so there shouldn’t be issues with the collar or clasp breaking apart any time soon.
Price: This is definitely a little costly for a basic dog collar, though that can be chalked up to the extra nylon layer as well as the donation they make to rescue dogs from your purchase.
If you’re trying to train your dog, but worried about a Martingale not doing enough to keep them in line or a prong being too much brute force strength, you can try a shock collar. This one happens to have other settings besides the shock (which customer say only feels like the static shock you’d get by rubbing your feet on the floor), so you can train your dog using a series of beeps or vibrations, too.
Some customers say the shock stops working after a short while, which obviously defeats the purpose. However, there is a lifetime guarantee with this collar and customer service is fantastic, so this shouldn’t be a concern.
Style: This is what’s known as a shock training collar, though it’s a bit of a misnomer as it doesn’t have to deliver a shock if you don’t want it to. You can customize how it works and control it with a well-lit and easy to read LCD remote.
Comfort: Despite the actual discomfort of the collar stimulation, your dog should feel comfortable enough wearing this out and about.
Security: The whole point of this collar is security. So if you’re nervous about your dog chewing off their collar, trying to run off, or escape outside your property’s boundaries, this is a good collar choice.
Price: Well, considering this is more than just a piece of nylon that goes around your neck, this high price includes the cost of the technology too.
Want to keep a better eye on your dog when you take him or her on nighttime walks or hikes? You could use a reflective collar, but that just won’t cut it if you need greater visibility. That’s why this bright LED collar is what you should be using.
Some people said the battery died after a few days to a few months of use. However, there is a lifetime guarantee on this, so you can get it replaced if you run into any issues.
Style: This is a dog collar that actually lights up. You can choose from a number of settings too, so if you prefer a steady stream of light, a slow flash, or quick pulse, you can use this collar to improve visibility of your dog when he or she is outside.
Comfort: A few customers said they liked how the rubber of the collar doesn’t catch on the dogs fur. It’s also pretty lightweight, so most of them don’t even notice it’s there.
Security: If you’re tired of an attachable light bouncing around as you try to keep tabs on your dog in the dark, this LED dog collar will provide you with much better visibility of their whereabouts. And because it’s an actual collar, it will stay put as opposed to an attachment that could otherwise be pulled or chewed off.
Price: Well, considering this is much cheaper than some tactical LED flashlights you might be carrying around on you—and there’s a lifetime guarantee—we'd consider the cost of this one negligible.
Family Living Today and Top Dog Tips gave this leather dog collar rave reviews for its high-quality construction and comfort. Add to that a lifetime guarantee, and this collar is a smart choice if your dog is rough on its collars and you want to give them something that makes them look stylish.
Customers have had issues with the sizing on these collars, so contact the company if you have any questions or concerns there. Also, some people with lighter dogs have reported that the collar of the collar rubbed off on their fur.
Style: This is your basic dog collar, so not ideal for training or other specialized purposes.
Comfort: Customers say that the wider band and well-made leather is much more comfortable for dogs than the thinner nylon ones.
Security: So long as you get the right size, your dog shouldn’t be able to slip out of this collar. It’s also not easy to chew or break, so you won’t have to worry about fido finding another way out.
Price: While this is a little expensive for a dog collar, you’re paying for the high-quality craftsmanship. And considering you have a lifetime guarantee, you won’t have to pay for another one again, which makes this a fantastic deal.
One of the best things about this dog collar? It makes no noise! If you’re one of those people who doesn’t like to hear your dog bouncing around the house while you’re trying to work or sleep or attend to the kids, you’ll love this custom-engraved leather dog collar. And so will your pup (though probably for other reasons)!
Just be careful about the sizing on this one. Since the engraving goes right on the leather, it’s not returnable.
Style: This is a basic leather dog collar. It also happens to come in a variety of beautiful colors, with a personalized engraving for your dog’s name and contact info, as well as a choice of bone, heart, or paw print designs.
Comfort: People love how soft the leather of this collar it. They even say that the leather still looks new even after the dog’s worn it for some time, so it appears to be pretty durable too.
Security: Instead of using a typical clasp or buckle to close it, this comes with belt-like loops to secure this around your dog’s neck. And, because your dog’s info is engraved right on the collar, you don’t have to worry about a metal ring or ID tag falling off if your dog should run away.
Price: This is about average price for a dog collar, though the personalized engraving and leather craftsmanship actually makes this product quite a steal.